Question
upstudy study bank question image url

Increasingly, Congress is concerned with the eradication of disloyalty and the defense of Americanism, and scarcely a day passes...that the outlines of the new loyalty and the new Americanism are not etched more sharply in public policy...In the making is a revival of the red hysteria of the early 1920s, one of the shabbiest chapters in the history of American democracy...What is this new loyalty? It is, above all, conformity. It is the uncritical and unquestioning acceptance of America as it is-the political institutions, the social relationships, the economic practices...The concept of loyalty as conformity is a false one. It is narrow and restrictive, denies freedom of thought and of conscience... What do men know of loyalty who make a mockery of the Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights? What lines of reasoning does Commager use to support his opinion of the anticommunist crusade's effect on Americans' liberties? Correct Answer(s) Drag appropriate answer(s) here Commager points out that this "new loyalty" could be viewed as restrictive because it denies freedom of thought and conscience. Commager unfavorably draws a comparison between the mistake of the 1920 s red hysteria to the nation's most recent approach to anticommunism. Commager explains that the "new loyalty" means that citizens are encouraged to question society, economics, and politics to become better citizens.

Ask by Bowers Norris. in the United States
Mar 16,2025

Upstudy AI Solution

Tutor-Verified Answer

Answer

Commager argues that the "new loyalty" is restrictive because it limits freedom of thought and conscience. He also compares the current anticommunist approach unfavorably to the 1920s red hysteria, suggesting it may harm civil liberties.

Solution

Sign in to Unlock Answers for Free!

A Learning Platform Trusted by Millions of Real Students and Teachers.

star-icon Unlock

Answered by UpStudy AI and reviewed by a Professional Tutor

Extra Insights

Commager effectively argues that this "new loyalty" is a form of oppression rather than a genuine expression of patriotism, emphasizing how it stifles individual thought and conscience. He contrasts the ideals of the Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights with this narrow definition of loyalty, asserting that true loyalty should include critical engagement and dissent rather than blind conformity to existing structures. He also draws a parallel between the anticommunist crusade of his time and the red hysteria of the 1920s, suggesting that both movements represented a dangerous threat to American democracy. According to Commager, the historical context serves as a cautionary tale, reminding citizens that suppressing dissent in the name of national loyalty undermines the very freedoms that define America.

Related Questions

-KTRACT C Thami: I told you, I'm not sure, l'm not sure about anything yet. Isabel: What does Mr M say? Thami: le's got nothing to do with him. Isabel: But you'ro his favourito, aren't you? [Non-commital shrug from Thami] I bet you are. And I also bet you anything you like that he's got a career planned out for you. Thami: [Sharply] What I do with my life has got nothing to do with him. Isabel: Sorry. [Act 1 Scene 1] 4.1.1 During the school debate Mr M interrupts Thami and isabel to remind them about how a debate should be conducted. What does he tell them? (4) 4.1.2 Refer to line 1 (I'm not sure about anything yer). What is it that Thami is not sure of? (1) 4.1.3 Refer to line 3 (If's got nothing to do with him). If you were the director of this play, what tone of voice would you tell Thami to use when saying these words? Explain your answer. (2) 4.1.4 Refer to line 4 (But you're his favourite, aren't you?). Give TWO reasons why Thami is Mr Ms favourite. (2) 4.1.5 After the debate, when lgabel is alone, she says that she has 'discovered a new world'. What does she mean by this? (2) 4. 16 Refer to line 19 (You got a \( \qquad \) How about that!) What does this line suggest about how Thami feels about lsabel's school having a newspaper? (1) 4.1.7 What does this extract reveal about Isabel's character? Explain your answer. (2) 4.1.8 Consider the play as a whole. Do you think Thami makes a wise decision to partiopate in the student protest? Discuss your view. (3) Do you think Thami makes the right decision to join the protest at school? Is Mr M a good teacher? Act 1 Scone2 EXTRACT A (p.53) Isabol: I'm not saying I've had no contact \( \qquad \) that has never happened to me before. 1 Complete the following sentences by using the words in the list below. Write only the word next to the question number 1.1 (a) \( \mathbf{- 1 . 1} \) (b) in the answer-book black; multicultural; white; autocracy; Democracy, Indians, Apartheid Communist The message of this extract is that although isabel is (a) \( \qquad \) and thus not a beneficiary of (b) \( \qquad \) laws, her meeting and communication with (c) \( \qquad \) peopie for a day radically changes her perspective. [3] 2. Refer to lines 8 and 9 . (He is a staunch Zionist ...the baas daughter that he's talking to. ) What do we leam about Samuel in these lines? [2] Pape3d 19
English South Africa Mar 15, 2025

Latest English Questions

Try Premium now!
Try Premium and ask Thoth AI unlimited math questions now!
Maybe later Go Premium
Study can be a real struggle
Why not UpStudy it?
Select your plan below
Premium

You can enjoy

Start now
  • Step-by-step explanations
  • 24/7 expert live tutors
  • Unlimited number of questions
  • No interruptions
  • Full access to Answer and Solution
  • Full Access to PDF Chat, UpStudy Chat, Browsing Chat
Basic

Totally free but limited

  • Limited Solution
Welcome to UpStudy!
Please sign in to continue the Thoth AI Chat journey
Continue with Email
Or continue with
By clicking “Sign in”, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy