Question
upstudy study bank question image url

QUEsTION 192 polnts Can It Pass the Test? The Tinker Test says schools can't restrict student speech unless it (1) disrupts learning or (2) violates another student's rights. Use the Tinker Test and identify the correct response to the situation. A student places a political sticker on the outside of her locker that says a particular ethnic group is dangerous. sELECT AN answEr Restrict - It disrupts learning. Restrict - It violates another student's rights. Don't restrict - It's freedom of speech.

Ask by Huff Norton. in the United States
Mar 11,2025

Upstudy AI Solution

Tutor-Verified Answer

Answer

The correct response is to restrict the speech because it violates another student's rights.

Solution

1. The Tinker Test establishes that schools may not restrict student speech unless it either: - Disrupts the learning process, or - Violates the rights of another student. 2. In this scenario, the student places a political sticker on her locker with a message claiming a particular ethnic group is dangerous. This message is likely to make students who identify with that ethnic group feel unsafe or targeted. 3. Since the sticker's content can be seen as violating the rights of those affected by creating a hostile environment (even if it doesn't necessarily cause widespread disruption to learning), the speech falls under the second exception. 4. Therefore, according to the Tinker Test, the correct response is to restrict the speech because it violates another student's rights. Answer: Restrict - It violates another student's rights.

Answered by UpStudy AI and reviewed by a Professional Tutor

error msg
Explain
Simplify this solution

Beyond the Answer

The Tinker Test, originating from the landmark Supreme Court case Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District (1969), established that students do not lose their First Amendment rights at the school gate. However, if the speech in question causes significant disruption or infringes on the rights of others, schools can step in. In this situation, the political sticker could be considered a violation of another student's rights, especially if it fosters a hostile environment based on ethnicity. While the First Amendment protects freedom of speech, it has limitations in schools. Placing a sticker that labels an ethnic group as dangerous might incite hostility and potentially disrupt the learning environment. Therefore, the correct response is to restrict, as it violates another student's rights.

Related Questions

Latest Social Sciences Questions

Try Premium now!
Try Premium and ask Thoth AI unlimited math questions now!
Maybe later Go Premium
Study can be a real struggle
Why not UpStudy it?
Select your plan below
Premium

You can enjoy

Start now
  • Step-by-step explanations
  • 24/7 expert live tutors
  • Unlimited number of questions
  • No interruptions
  • Full access to Answer and Solution
  • Full Access to PDF Chat, UpStudy Chat, Browsing Chat
Basic

Totally free but limited

  • Limited Solution
Welcome to UpStudy!
Please sign in to continue the Thoth AI Chat journey
Continue with Email
Or continue with
By clicking “Sign in”, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy